Did the crowd number “about five thousand” (John 6:10)?
The “men” (John 6:10) numbered about
5000. Including the “women and children” (Matthew
14:21), the crowd probably numbered about
15000 or more.
What other clues are there to the size of this crowd?
One denarius (plural: denarii) was the wage for one day's labor, so
“two hundred
denarii
worth of bread” (John 6:7)
was the amount of bread that could be bought with about eight months'
(including rest on the Sabbath) income. Imagine spending what you
earn in eight
months to buy just bread and it still being “not
sufficient for them, that every one of them may receive a little”
(John 6:7). This was a massive crowd.
What was Andrew describing when he said, “There is a boy
here who has five barley loaves and two small fish” (John 6:9)?
The “barley loaves” would be comparable to
today's dinner
rolls, and the two fish were “small”; this was a kid's
meal.
How did Andrew find it?
Jesus had told him and the other disciples to go and look for bread among
the crowd: He
said to them, “How many loaves
do
you have? Go and see.” And when they knew, they
said, “Five, and two fish”
(Mark 6:38).
What does their answer imply?
Reporting back about a kid's meal and even mentioning fish, which Jesus
didn't ask about, implies that they looked for all food items, including
bread, and the kid's meal was all that they found.
Honestly, do you believe the account above?
How can anyone feed 5000, 15000 or even more people with a kid’s
meal, and then
end up with more food afterward than before?
Do you believe a baby can complete a marathon?
Do you believe an Olympic marathoner could?
What is the point?
We call something a “miracle” when someone does something that exceeds our
estimation of their ability. But our estimation can be an underestimation,
and mistaking an Olympic marathoner for a baby is a far smaller
underestimation than mistaking the Creator of the universe for a creature.
For
Jesus, the Creator God - “For by Him all
things were created, those in the heavens and those upon the earth, those visible and
those invisible, whether thrones or lordships or rulers or authorities. All
things were created through Him and for Him” (Colossians 1:16) -
feeding a few thousand people with even nothing at all would have been a piece of
cake, and this applies to all of His other miracles recorded in the Bible.