Why do the Pharisees ask the formerly blind man what
he thinks?
Religious leaders suddenly asking a street beggar for his opinion on
a theological issue indicates how desperate they were to find a way to
resolve the
conflict between the miraculous “sign” (John 9:16) from
God and their man-made laws about the Sabbath.
Why did they “not believe concerning him, that he
had been blind and then had received his sight” (John 9:18)?
They decided to try to resolve the conflict by continuing to uphold their man-made
Sabbath laws (see
Pharisees) and claiming that the miraculous “sign” from God
never took place.
Is his reply - “He is a prophet” (John 9:17) - what
they want to hear?
No, so they throw up their hands and decide to wait for his parents to arrive and
to hopefully tell them what they want to hear.
Do his parents tell the Jews' what they want to hear?
No, they defer back to their healed son: “We
know that this is our son, and that he was born blind. But how he now sees we do not know, or who opened his eyes we
do not know. He is of age; ask him. He will speak for himself”
(John 9:20-21).
What should his parents have done instead?
Greet their healed son with tears of joy, tell the Jews to leave him
alone, go and find, thank, and worship Jesus for having healed their son, and then
throw a party to celebrate.
Why did his parents say what they said above?
“They were afraid of the Jews, for the Jews already had agreed that anyone
who confesses Him Christ would be put out
of the synagogue” (John 9:22).
What was the big deal about being put out of the
synagogue? Couldn't they just join
another synagogue down the street or do without it?
For Jews, life back then revolved around the synagogue, which was the center of
their social,
religious and economic life. There was one synagogue per community, so being
“put out” of it meant the end of one's social and religious
life in that community, and economic hardship.
If you belong to a church, have you ever agreed with
what is false or not said what is true for fear of losing your status
within or being ostracized by your congregation?