Where does Pilate question Jesus?
Inside the Praetorium, away from the Jews,
who are just outside its gate (see Praetorium
for why they do not wish to enter).
How serious was Pilate when he asked Jesus, "Are You
the King of the Jews" (John 18:33)?
If
Pilate really thought Jesus is the king of the Jews, he wouldn't have
lent one-tenth of his legion to the Jews (see
Judas Iscariot) just a few hours earlier to arrest Jesus. Pilate
probably posed the question to Jesus with at least some incredulity, if
not sarcasm at a man who was dressed nothing like a king.
Then why did Pilate pose the question at all to
Jesus?
Pilate was holding a trial and giving the defendant an opportunity to
defend Himself against the charges His accusers have brought against
Him.
How does Jesus reply to Pilates question?
Instead of defending Himself, Jesus responds with a question that
implies He is indeed a king and turns the tables on Pilate by
questioning if he recognizes this himself or is simply relaying what he
has heard from others.
What does Pilate mean by, "Am I a Jew? Your own
nation and the chief priests have delivered You to me" (John 18:35)?
'I am a Roman and the governor, not some Jew, and I am only relaying the
charges against you.'
What does Pilate mean by "What have You done" (John
18:35)?
'You're obviously not a king, so what are you really guilty of?'
What does Pilate already appear to have ruled out?
That Jesus is some rebel leader who declared Himself king to lead an
armed rebellion against the Roman rule.
What must the Roman officers who led the six hundred
Roman soldiers to arrest Jesus have reported to Pilate after returning to their
barracks?
That there had been no battle, no loss of life, and that Jesus had come
forward and voluntarily and repeatedly identified Himself (see
Jesus of Nazareth), and let Himself be arrested without a
struggle (see
Malchus).